Who watches the watchmen: Accountability, spiritual authority and institutional power in the House of God (11)

By Lanre Ogundipe

A church may have a constitution, trustees, a governing board, financial officers and an elaborate administrative structure, yet still be governed by one man whose decisions nobody dares to question. The structures may exist. Accountability may not.

This is one of the uncomfortable questions confronting the modern religious institution: who watches the watchmen when spiritual authority becomes institutional power, and those appointed to provide oversight are unwilling to challenge it?

The question is not an indictment of the Church. It is an examination of the machinery through which the Church governs itself, particularly when substantial resources, property, commercial interests and the loyalty of thousands of worshippers converge around a dominant personality.

A ministry may begin with a genuine calling, grow through sacrifice and become an institution of enormous influence. But growth brings responsibilities that personal conviction alone cannot discharge. The larger the institution becomes, the less sustainable governance by unquestioned personal authority becomes.

The founder may possess the vision. The pastor may command the congregation. Neither position automatically confers immunity from accountability.

WHEN THE BOARD BECOMES A RUBBER STAMP

The existence of trustees or a governing board is often presented as evidence of institutional accountability. But the real test is not whether a board exists. It is whether it can independently discharge its responsibilities.

Who examines major financial decisions? Who questions contracts, expenditure, investments and property transactions? Who challenges a proposal when its financial implications are questionable? Who can insist that the constitution be obeyed, even when doing so inconveniences the principal spiritual authority?

A board that merely approves what the founder has already decided may satisfy an administrative formality without fulfilling its governance responsibility.

This is where personality driven ministries become vulnerable. When appointments, influence and institutional advancement depend excessively on the approval of one individual, independent scrutiny may become difficult. Board members may begin to confuse loyalty to the founder with loyalty to the institution.

But the two are not necessarily the same.

A governing board exists to protect the institution, its mission, its resources and its continuity. Its duty is not to preserve the unquestioned authority of any individual, however revered.

A board that cannot disagree when disagreement is necessary has surrendered one of the most important functions for which it exists.

TRUSTEES: CUSTODIANS OR COMPLIANT OFFICERS?

The legal responsibilities of incorporated trustees are not matters of spiritual interpretation alone. The Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 provides a framework for the constitution, administration and obligations of incorporated associations.

Sections 827, 838 and 846 address, respectively, aspects of the constitution of incorporated trustees, the application of income and property in accordance with the association’s objects, and the maintenance of accounting records.

These obligations reinforce an elementary principle: institutional property and resources are held and administered for the purposes of the organisation, not simply at the personal discretion of whoever exercises the greatest influence within it.

A founder does not automatically become the beneficial owner of the institution’s assets. A pastor’s spiritual standing does not erase the responsibilities of trustees. Trusteeship is not a ceremonial appointment, nor should it be reduced to a position of unquestioning loyalty.

Yet the crucial question remains whether those entrusted with protecting the institution can exercise that responsibility independently.

Where trustees are unwilling to challenge the founder, where institutional decisions are made outside established procedures, or where the constitution becomes subordinate to personal directives, the organisation may possess legal and administrative structures without effective governance.

The danger is not merely a possible breach of law. It is the erosion of institutional safeguards that should protect the ministry from the excesses of any individual.

WHEN QUESTIONS BECOME DISLOYALTY

In some religious environments, the problem goes beyond weak governance. It extends to the culture surrounding authority.

A member who asks about expenditure may be accused of lacking faith. An officer who questions a decision may be branded rebellious. A request for transparency may be interpreted as an attempt to undermine the pastor or attack the ministry.

This culture, where it exists, creates an atmosphere in which silence becomes safer than responsibility.

The consequence is particularly troubling when those who contribute financially are discouraged from asking legitimate questions about the use of institutional resources. Giving may be preached as an act of faith, but faith does not abolish the obligation to administer contributions honestly.

The Scriptures do not endorse unquestioned human authority. The Bereans were commended for examining what they heard against the Scriptures. Discernment was not rebellion. Examination was not disrespect.

The Church must therefore distinguish between an attack on its mission and a legitimate demand that those entrusted with its affairs account for their decisions.

To equate every question with disloyalty is to create a protection around authority that the Gospel itself does not require.

THE MONEY THAT NOBODY QUESTIONS

Weak oversight becomes especially consequential when institutional money is involved.

Churches receive offerings, tithes, donations, building contributions, special appeals and funds designated for specific purposes. Some undertake investments, commercial ventures, property development and other activities requiring substantial financial management.

The more complex the financial operations, the more essential independent controls become.

Who authorises expenditure? Who verifies transactions? Who examines accounts? Who supervises procurement? Who monitors designated funds? Who investigates allegations involving senior officials?

Good intentions cannot replace financial controls. Trust cannot substitute for records. A reputation for holiness cannot eliminate the need for transparent accounting.

Paul understood this principle. In organising the collection for believers in Jerusalem, he took deliberate precautions in its administration so that the handling of the money would not be open to suspicion. In 2 Corinthians 8:20–21, he emphasised the need to act honourably, not only before God but also before men.

The lesson is striking. Even in the administration of a charitable Christian undertaking, spiritual sincerity did not make safeguards unnecessary.

If the apostolic example recognised the importance of protecting financial integrity through responsible administration, why should modern religious institutions consider scrutiny an inconvenience?

The money belongs to the purpose for which it was entrusted. The people who administer it have an obligation to demonstrate that the trust has been honoured.

WHEN THE FOUNDER BECOMES THE INSTITUTION

The founder’s vision may be the reason a ministry exists. His sacrifice may have laid its foundation, his preaching may have attracted its congregation, and his leadership may have sustained its growth. But the institution must eventually become bigger than the personality that created it.

Where the founder controls appointments, finances, succession, property decisions and the governing structures, institutional continuity may depend more on personal authority than on established procedures.

The danger becomes apparent when succession arises. Who determines the next leader? What happens when the founder dies, becomes incapacitated or withdraws? Can the institution survive disagreement over succession without splintering into factions?

A ministry that has accumulated enormous resources but failed to establish credible succession and independent governance may be wealthy in assets and poor in institutional resilience.

The founder may have built the house. He cannot legitimately turn the house into an inheritance of personal power simply because he built it.

THE SCRIPTURAL TEST

Peter warned elders against shepherding for dishonest gain or exercising authority as dominators over those entrusted to their care. Paul declared in 1 Corinthians 4:2 that stewards must be found faithful.

These are not ornamental biblical principles. They are standards by which leadership must be examined.

Faithfulness is not measured by the size of a congregation, the number of branches, the value of properties, the visibility of a ministry or the unquestioning loyalty of its followers. It is measured by how faithfully those entrusted with responsibility discharge it.

Jesus did not present leadership as domination. He presented service as its defining obligation.

A church that demands accountability from government, condemns corruption in public office and insists that political leaders answer for their stewardship cannot consistently exempt its own leadership from the same moral principle.

The standards cannot change simply because the institution carries a religious identity.

THE WATCHMEN MUST ALSO BE WATCHED

The Church does not lose its authority by submitting to accountability. It loses credibility when it resists accountability while demanding it from everyone else.

Trustees must protect the institution. Boards must exercise independent judgement. Financial officers must maintain accurate records. Pastors must recognise the distinction between spiritual authority and institutional control. Congregations must not be conditioned to believe that asking legitimate questions is an act of rebellion.

Not every church is guilty of governance failure. Many operate responsibly, maintain proper structures, administer resources faithfully and provide services that benefit communities far beyond their congregations. They deserve recognition, not suspicion.

But responsible institutions should not be offended by the questions that irresponsible ones fear.

The real test of a religious institution is not simply how much it has built, acquired, raised or achieved. It is whether the authority, resources and influence entrusted to it remain subject to the purpose for which they were given.

The watchmen must watch. The trustees must protect. The boards must question. The shepherd must serve.

For nobody entrusted with the affairs of God’s house should mistake the privilege of authority for ownership of the institution, or the silence of the congregation for proof of faithful stewardship.

Possession is not the problem. Stewardship is the question.

Ogundipe, Public Affairs Analyst, Former President Nigeria and Africa Union of Journalists and itinerant Bible teacher, writes from Abuja

Related posts

Jimmy Odukoya, please don’t say bye bye: An open letter to a wounded soldier of Christ

Church belongs to no individual, says Bishop Odedeji at dedication of 170-year-old Agboyi Anglican new edifice

Agboyi: The Rebirth of 170-Year-Old Anglican Church